Did you just come back from your local fish store with a new goldfish and some tetras? You might be asking if they can live together. Sadly, the answer is no. I understand—you’re likely thinking, “But they’re both small fish! They should get along. Goldfish are cold water creatures and much larger than tropical tetras, which made them more likely to eat the smaller ones due to their voracious appetite.
In this article, I’ll explain why combining these two beautiful types might not work out, even though they look great together in theory.
Understanding Goldfish Needs
When thinking about keeping goldfish with tetras, it’s important to understand basic care needs. I’ve learned that while goldfish are beautiful and come in many color types, they are not ideal tank mates for tropical fish like tetras. Goldfish grow rapidly and can get quite large—an average fully-grown goldfish can reach four to seven inches, sometimes even 18 inches long and weigh up to 10 pounds. Many factors such as diet, tank size, and health impact their growth, and a major part of how a goldfish develops is the space it lives in. It’s a popular belief that goldfish don’t live long, but that’s not true.
They can live a long life, with an expectancy of up to 49 years, if given proper conditions. Sadly, some are still kept in small bowls, which greatly limits their potential growth. If you keep them in a bowl, expect a lifespan of about five years, but in an indoor aquarium, they can live up to ten years, and in an outdoor pond with healthy water conditions, even 20 years. One downside I’ve noticed is they are quite messy and tend to taint the water quality, and since they like cooler temperatures—around 23-24°C—they are very different from tropical species like tetras.
Understanding Neon Tetra Needs
Neon tetras are some of the most beautiful and popular fish among beginner and expert fish keepers alike. Their stunning colors—bright red, glowing blue, and sometimes translucent—make them a favorite in many aquarium setups. These small fish, usually measuring around 1.5 inches, though some specimens may grow up to 2.5 inches, are known for their peaceful nature and ability to hide from predators thanks to their semi-clear bodies.
Because they don’t become large, they make good tank mates for other species that are approximately the same size. Many people really enjoy keeping freshwater fish like tetras not only because they’re aesthetically pleasing, but also because they bring a calming presence and are relatively easy to acquire. However, they should not be left alone—these fish thrive in groups.
To keep tetras truly happy, it’s best to house at least 15 members of their species together. The more companions they have, the happier and more active they become, which also benefits you by making your tank look more livelier and visually appealing. Since tetras are quite sensitive to changes in water conditions, they shouldn’t be introduced into a newly cycled tank. Instead, they should be placed in an established tank with peaceful fish that don’t cause a disturbance.
Tetras also prefer warmer temperatures, staying most comfortable between 28 to 30°C. If kept in a proper indoor enclosure, they can live up to five years, but their lifespan can reach eight when maintained in a healthy outdoor pond.
Can Goldfish and Neon Tetras Live Together? Here’s Why Not
Goldfish and neon tetras cannot live together because they need different living conditions and have different preferences. These include:
Water Temperature Difference
Both goldfish and neon tetras, one of the biggest challenges in managing water temperature. This is extremely important to consider because it directly affects the health and well-being of your fish. Goldfish are a coldwater species that thrive in cooler environments, ideally around 73–75°F (23–24°C). In contrast, tropical neon tetras need warmer water to stay healthy, with ideal temperatures between 82–86°F (28–30°C) to support proper growth. This difference in temperature needs creates a problem when trying to keep them in the same tank.
If these two species are put together, one of them will be forced into suboptimal living conditions. Based on what I’ve seen, this can quickly harm either fish. The goldfish may become sluggish and stressed in warmer water, while the neon tetras may suffer in colder temperatures. Eventually, this can lead to disease and death. Because of their opposite needs, they simply cannot live comfortably in the same tank, no matter how peaceful or compatible they might seem.
Different Feeding Requirements
Goldfish often have difficulty digesting certain foods, so their diet needs to be made up of food that’s specifically designed for them. Most owners prefer to feed them flakes or pellets because these are easy to digest and gentle on their system. Feeding tropical fish food to goldfish, however, can make the digestion process more complicated and stressful for them.
On the contrary, tropical food is the primary feeding source for neon tetras, and they do quite well on it. While tetras can consume goldfish flakes or pellets, they need it in smaller pieces due to their size. This clear difference in dietary needs makes it hard to maintain a shared feeding routine, and just like water temperature, it becomes another reason why these two species shouldn’t be kept in the same tank.
Tank Size
Housing goldfish requires more planning than keeping neon tetras. For example, a Comet goldfish alone needs at least a 30-gallon tank because they grow very fast and need huge spaces to live comfortably and avoid stress. From experience, I can say that outdoor ponds or very large tanks are often recommended for owners who want their fish to lead long, happy lives.
In contrast, a small tank setup is best suited only for neon tetras. These smaller fish do well in tighter environments, but if you add goldfish as companions, problems begin to surface. Over time, the goldfish will eventually outgrow the tetras and may even pose a threat to their safety. This space difference in needs is another strong reason why mixing the two is not a good idea.
Water Change Frequency
When it comes to water maintenance, Tetras are extremely sensitive to changes in their water, and they thrive better in a stable environment with fewer water changes. Doing too many water changes can actually be detrimental to their health. Since they produce less waste, they don’t require much tank maintenance, which makes them easier to manage in terms of cleanliness and routine care.
By contrast, goldfish are known to be messy fish. They create a messy environment by producing waste often and in great amounts, quickly dirtying the tank. I’ve also noticed that goldfish are naturally inquisitive creatures—they swim around actively and often nibble on objects as they investigate their surroundings. These habits not only increase the frequency of water contamination but also demand more frequent tank cleaning. These differences make it clear that maintaining one tank for both species isn’t ideal.
Vulnerability to Diseases
Goldfish are more vulnerable to diseases, especially in warm waters, because their immune system tends to get suppressed under such conditions. On the other hand, neon tetras, being a tropical fish species, are less likely to succumb to disease in the same environment. This natural difference in adaptability gives tetras an advantage, but it also introduces serious risks when both species share a tank.
Neon tetras can carry pathogens that are harmful to goldfish, and in some cases, may even potentially infect them. Since goldfish lack resistance to diseases carried by tropical fish, they become easy targets for infections. Consequently, even if the tetra appears healthy and happy, it could still be transmitting deadly disease spores to your unsuspecting goldfish friend. This hidden risk is one of the most overlooked reasons why keeping these two species together is unsafe.
Social Behaviors
Neon tetras are highly social creatures that feel safest and happiest when kept in a group. In the wild, they live in large schools made up of hundreds of tetras. In captivity, it’s recommended to keep about 8-12 neon tetras together so they stay comfortable and secure. If they are kept in pairs or alone, they often become anxious, stressed, and more susceptible to disease due to the lack of companionship.
Goldfish, while known for their friendly behaviors toward other fish, behave differently under stress. If their environment becomes overcrowded, they can turn aggressive and pose a threat to a peaceful school of tetras. Moreover, as goldfish grow larger, they naturally try to eat anything that fits in their mouth, including small fish like neon tetras. For this reason, placing them in separate tanks is the safest way to avoid any potential conflict or harm to either species.
What to Do If You Only Have One Tank
In such cases, you can place tetras and small goldfish together during the first four months. At that stage, the goldfish isn’t a major threat—they aren’t big enough yet to consume their mates, the neon tetras, or make too much of a mess. I’ve done this myself, and it worked for a while with close monitoring.
However, once the goldfish reach around six months old, they may start exhibiting more menacing qualities as they grow. That’s the point where things can get risky. By then, it’s best to transfer them to separate environments. The ideal place to keep goldfish long-term is outdoors in ponds or large fish tanks, where they have more space and don’t pose a danger to smaller fish like tetras.
Why Goldfish May Eat Smaller Fish Like Tetras
If you’re considering housing goldfish and tetras together, here’s something crucial to know—goldfish can and often will eat tetras. It’s an unsettling reality that many new fishkeepers overlook until it’s too late.
Natural Instinct and Size Dynamic
The issue of natural behavior and size difference between goldfish and tetras is more serious than many people realize. Goldfish can grow substantially over time, even if you’ve purchased a variety that starts off on the smaller side. They have the potential for significant growth, while tetras, especially neon ones, stay relatively tiny throughout their lives. This disparity in size makes it easy for tetras to be seen as food rather than suitable tank mates.
On top of that, goldfish have a strong natural instinct to eat whatever fits in their mouth. They are opportunistic eaters—not very picky—and the quick movement of a smaller fish like a darting tetra can easily trigger their predatory instincts. To a goldfish, that fast motion might resemble the tasty worms or insects they would normally snack on in the wild. This instinct-driven behavior further proves why these two species are not a safe match in one tank.
FAQs
Can goldfish live with neon tetras?
Goldfish and neon tetras aren’t a good match. Goldfish need cooler water and create heavy waste, while tetras need warm, clean, tropical conditions.
What fish should you not put with goldfish?
Goldfish should not be kept with certain fish. Avoid small, finned species like neon tetras, guppies, or danios, as goldfish may eat them. Also, steer clear of aggressive or territorial fish like cichlids, bettas, or most barbs, as they can stress or harm your goldfish.
Conclusion
It’s completely tempting to keep all your favorite fish together in one tank, but it’s important to remember that different species have different needs. With a clear understanding of each fish’s care requirements, social habits, and vulnerabilities, you can create a more harmonious environment where all your aquatic pets can truly thrive.
This article was written to help you better understand the differences between goldfish and neon tetras, so you can make the right choices. If you have any questions or want to share your own experiences, feel free to leave a comment below.
You may also like:
- Can Betta Fish and Cherry Shrimp Share a Tank?
- Can Snails Live with Bettas?
- Are Betta Fish Compatible with Goldfish?
- Can Betta Fish & Guppies Live Together?
- Mollies and Bettas in One Tank?
- Is It Safe? African Dwarf Frogs & Bettas in the Same Tank
Also read for extra betta care!
